Mapping

 

Mapping activities help explore themes of access and control focusing on questions of where, what, and who. Some common versions include mobility maps and resource mapping.

 

Related Approaches and Tools

Participatory Rural Appraisal

Digital Tools

Thematic Analysis

Sensemaking Workshop

Generating Insights

Mapping is an excellent way to understand physical space and the impact on different types of people. Maps can explore what resources are accessible where, as well as how different individuals are able to move and travel.

For MEL, mapping can be used in four different ways:

  1. Observational– single point of time reflecting on the present
  2. Retrospective – single point of time reflecting on the past
  3. Comparative – single point of time comparing different types of people
  4. Longitudinal – multiple points of time comparing different responses of the same people

Mapping has four objectives:

  • Encourage participants to reflect on their own lives
  • Help participants identify their own mobility restrictions
  • Start deeper conversations around complex topics (e.g. who is allowed where and when, and safety issues and social norms)
  • Collect GESI-related insights through mapping outputs
Step 1. Clarify the objective and modality of mapping

In this first step, facilitators will need to reflect on exactly what they hope to achieve by mapping. This includes who the participants are, and how it will be conducted. Some points to think through include:

  • Online facilitation, interviews or focus groups?
  • Transect walk or pens and paper?
  • What theme will be explored? For example: Mobility/travel, access to resources, toilet access, water access, clinics access, market/bazaar access?
  • Change agents, beneficiaries, or staff?
Step 2. Prepare the materials

Identify the physical prompts to be used in mapping. We recommend testing any tools with a variety of participants before starting. Add visuals and translate as required. Laminate cards or templates if they will be used frequently.

Mobility maps are often conducted with a concentric circle diagram. The diagram can be prepared in advance. Each ring of the circle represents a different layer of the community, with the most central layer representing the smallest layer. For example home, village, ward, district, country. 

Step 3. Conduct mapping

During the interview, workshop or focus groups, and at the appropriate time, follow these subs-steps. It is better to conduct one-on-one interviews for more sensitive topics. However, group engagement can also allow for raising awareness.

Mobility Maps

  1. Introduce the map and clarify any templates or materials. 
  2. Clarify each area of the map to make sure the participant(s) understand the objectives.
  3. Ask participant(s) to identify the furthest location different types of people could travel to without restrictions. These could be organisational, familial, societal or even personal restrictions. They can point on the map and then draw a figure to represent this type of person.
  4. Use this to discuss the restrictions and whether there are ways a team can overcome them. What are the reasons for the restrictions? (Provide prompts – to do the right thing, safety, husband won’t let me etc).
  5. Make a note of important aspects that are useful for analysis: age, status gender, role, religion, ethnicity, experience, or other aspects.
  6. Write down observations and probe participant(s) to explain their decisions.

Community Maps

  1. Introduce the map and clarify any templates or materials. 
  2. Collaboratively identify what things will be drawn on the map. For example: clinics, schools, religious buildings, homes, sanitation, and water.  
  3. Ask participant(s) to draw the map and identify different aspects of it for different types of people.
  4. Use this to discuss the different levels of access and whether there are ways that communities can create more equitable distributions.
  5. Make a note of important aspects that are useful for analysis: age, status gender, role, religion, ethnicity, experience or other aspects.
  6. Write down observations and probe participant(s) to explain their decisions.
Step 4. Data analysis, sensemaking and sharing

The final step is to analyse the responses to identify key themes and share them with relevant stakeholders.

  • Compile Maps. With mobility maps, we recommend compiling the findings into a single document. We recommend using Excel or post-it notes and placing the map areas steps across the top of the page as columns. Then in each column add a quick description of the respondents who fall into each category. Break this down by age, gender, ethnicity or other aspects to find themes. This may take on a different shape if the analysis is longitudinal, comparative or retrospective. For community maps, there is not the same requirement for compilation.

Compiling Example 1

Participant Number

Home

Village

District

1

Free to move in her home

Free to move in her village

Needs husband’s permission to visit …..XXX

2

 

 

 

3

 

 

 

Compiling Example 2

People Types

Home

Village

District

Unmarried Women

Free to move in her home

Free to move in her village

Needs husband’s permission to visit …..XXX

Low-caste Women

 

 

 

Older Women

 

 

 

 

  • Sensemaking workshop. In a workshop setting, explore the data with a group of key stakeholders.
Travel Restricted Times

While mapping is best done in person, it can also be completed remotely using participatory methods.

Keeping in mind differences in access and literacy, think about different ways to facilitate and plan the activity.

Computer and internet access

  • Encourage participants to fill in a map on a collaborative platform (Mural, Micro, Google Slide or Google Sheet). This can be conducted individually or collaboratively as an interview, focus group, or workshop through audio/video conferencing.
  • Encourage participants to fill in a map through an online qualitative survey questionnaire (Mentimeter, Phonic, Google or Microsoft Forms, Kobo, Airtable)

Smartphone and internet access

  • Encourage participants to fill in a map through an online qualitative survey questionnaire (Mentimeter, Phonic, Google or Microsoft Forms, Kobo, Airtable)

Basic phone access

  • Collect information over the phone as an interview and have the enumerator fill in the canvases.

See an example of participatory activities using Google Slide.

Learn more on the digital tools page.

Mapping Canvases

This PDF document includes both mobility and community mapping canvas templates.

 
download

PPTX | 1,020 KB

Mobility Mapping

Mobility Maps help participants explore how and where they can travel and any restrictions with limited movement, either social and familial.

Community Mapping

Community Maps help participants explore the spatial and geographic distribution of resources and services within communities.

Learn More

Murthy R.K. (2015) Gender-Sensitive Participatory Evaluation Methods. New Delhi, India. (page 27)

 

Explore other techniques and tools

Ladders

Ladders

Ladders and Spectrums   Laddering activities help identify how individuals perceive themselves within a range of behaviours, activities, or viewpoints. Some common versions include participation, happiness, safety, wellbeing, and confidence.  Related Approaches...

Matrices

Matrices

Matrices   Matrix activities help identify societal and household norms. Some common versions include roles, responsibilities, opportunities, decisions, access, and social capital.   Related Approaches and Tools Matrix activities help identify social norms,...